Finally, the choice on whether to choose listed brands depends on your budget, the type of wood used on your floor, as well as the look of the color choice you want. Polyurethanes are the coatings used to protect your floor minwax vs varathane polyurethane from damage. Conventionally, three layers of this kind of finish are needed to ensure the longevity of the coating and protection of the floor. The type and brand you use for coating your floor are of crucial importance.

minwax vs varathane polyurethane

After “scrubbing” off the old wax layers, and sanding, I always finished them with tung oil. I didn’t know Waterlox contained tung…now all your posts make sense. So anyway, those are my thoughts on Waterlox vs. polyurethane, and also on Minwax stain.

Best Oil

I don’t like sanding between coats or the scratches in other finishes or trying to repair said scratches. Waterlox makes a UV product as well, good-by Helmsman Spar. I used Waterlox’s True Tone for my base coat to give the wood some color then top coated with either original or the marine formula if exposed to sunlight. Best stain results I ever got on pine, still some dark areas and reverse grain but no splotches or muddy areas. I love your “new” floors; they really are a much richer color.

If you want to apply sealer, you should use polycrylic paint because oil-based polyurethane can cause a yellow color tint. This can avoid the tint from seeping through the other layers you add onto the material. Formulated using a 450 VOC-compliant formula, this oil-based product is designed to be used in hard-to-reach areas both inside and outside. This includes use on doors, furniture, cabinets, and floors.

Should I Sand Between Polyurethane Spray Coats?

Those bubbles will end up on the brush and dry on the surface of the wood. Any bubbles will need to be sanded out before applying the next minwax vs varathane polyurethane coat. There are oil-based polyurethanes and water-based polyurethanes. Lacquer is often thought of as the best all-around finish for wood.

  • For these an additional step between sanding and staining is recommended – applying a layer of a sealer.
  • Most hardwax oil wood finishes only require a single application, while some require additional applications.
  • Both types are very durable and offer a great looking surfaces finish, however, there are some critical differences between them.
  • This poly is of incredible value as it is made from a tested and verified formula to give the clients great waterborne poly.
  • The finish will be much more durable, but will add an amber hue to the natural color of your wooden surface.

This is what my entryway, living room and music room floors looked like back in September 2013 right after I finished them with Waterlox. As a personal rule, I aim to avoid staining wood and rather look for reasons to not stain as opposed to looking for excuses minwax vs varathane polyurethane to stain. I love to bring out the look and figure of the grain naturally whenever possible. Again, I love General Finishes and have used just about all of their products. I like their stains a lot, and would recommend them to anyone looking to stain wood.

General Finishes High Performance Semi

Oil-based products are also more water-resistant, so soap and water spills won’t easily damage the floor. Polyurethane varnish is one of the best finishes for a countertop — it’s durable and, when applied properly, can be just as subtle as lacquer. Best of all, applying polyurethane doesn’t require spray equipment and is a job you can easily do yourself. The difference between oil- and water-based polyurethane varnish has more to do with the solvent than it does with the resin. Polycrylic can be defined as the antagonist of polyurethane.

First, it’s a tung oil product, and tung oil has been used to seal hardwood floors for a very long time. Polyurethane is renowned for its durability as a protective coating, which means that the liquid itself is quite thick and honey-like. This means that you will likely require a thinner before spraying your polyurethane. We suggest testing the polyurethane without the thinner first to see its consistency, after which you can decide whether or not you need to add thinner. You can use turpentine, paint thinner, mineral spirits, and even water to thin your polyurethane.

Can Odorless Polyurethane Be Used For Wood Tabletops?

The amount of oil in spar urethane makes it softer and more pliable compared to polyurethane which tends to be quite hard when dried. Arguably the most noticeable difference is the oil concentration between spar urethane and polyurethane. Spar urethane not only dries faster but also tends to not need as many coats or layers to get the shine that is associated with the product. Both spar urethane and polyurethane are applied to surfaces in roughly the same manner.

Lacquers do not require any additional molecules to become hard; once the solvent evaporates the resins solidify. That is why lacquers dry so quickly — within 5 to 10 minutes — and why the reintroduction of solvents reconstitutes a dry, lacquered surface. Knowing the differences between the chemical properties of lacquers and polyurethanes provides initial insight into each of their practical applications. Extremely helpful breakdown of the two products without all the non-sense you don’t need.

Given this product’s fast drying time and ease of cleanup, we’d even consider it for vertical surfaces, including window sills, stairs, and cabinets. These products dry a bit rough and need sanding between coats, which makes it harder to get a rich color with a smooth surface. If I need to sand and baby it, then I might as well just stain then finish the wood in two steps.

Author: Kay Burton